Despite a banking crisis, rising interest rates, the indictment of a former president, et al., the S&P 500 finished the 1Q23 with a 7.03% gain. However, within the U.S. Market, growth stocks were up 14.79% and value was up only .18%, according to Morningstar. Despite this quarter’s gains, the Morningstar Market Valuation estimate puts the market at 92% of fair value.
The Fed kept interest rates too low for too long. There’s plenty of blame for both sides of the aisle in Congress too. While inefficiencies need to be purged from the system, politicians try to address the suffering at the individual level of those directly impacted when marginally profitable businesses are forced to close.
The banking problems that surfaced in March 2023 are one of the unintended consequences of Fed policy. Low interest rates incentivized banks to stretch for yield by buying long duration bonds that exposed their asset portfolios to excessive interest rate risk. When Silicon Valley Bank faltered, the whole banking system became suspect, and we saw a contagion effect with depositors pulling funds from similar banks. The Government intervened by extending FDIC insurance.
It is unreasonable to expect that 10+ years of easy money will not create some financial moral hazard. Now that we’re getting off the sauce, we’ll see who has been swimming naked. I expect continued volatility until the second half of the year. Getting past the peak interest rate question, lower inflation, the regional bank solvency question will likely result in better equity markets by the end of the year.